Todd Carlson '07 Water Polo |  |
"Presented by the Naval Academy Athletic Association in honor of Vice Admiral James Calvert, Superintendent of the Naval Academy (1968-72), to the varsity letterman of the graduating class selected by the varsity coaches as having perservered the most in his or her career."
| Year | Name | Class | Sport |
| 1973 | Charles Munn | '73 | Crew |
| 1974 | Stephen Gilmore | '74 | Cross Country/Track |
| 1975 | Joseph Delpino | '75 | Soccer |
| 1976 | Georgie Moore | '76 | Lacrosse |
| 1977 | Roger Fleischer | '77 | Wrestling |
| 1978 | Arthur Athens | '78 | Lacrosse |
| 1979 | Thomas Shelly | '79 | Soccer |
| 1980 | Catherine Rayhill | '80 | Basketball |
| 1981 | Patrick Bailey | '81 | Track |
| 1982 | Thomas Savidge | '82 | Crew |
| 1983 | J. Bruce Ricketts | '83 | Squash |
| 1984 | Andrew Bigelow | '84 | Crew |
| 1985 | Robert Dishman | '85 | Baseball |
| 1986 | Brian O'Malley | '86 | Outdoor Track |
| 1987 | Doug Wojcik | '87 | Basketball |
| 1988 | Matthew Treaster | '88 | Wrestling |
| 1989 | Jeffrey Tomlin | '89 | Water Polo |
| 1990 | Edward Dewald | '90 | Wrestling |
| 1991 | John Quinn | '91 | Lacrosse |
| 1992 | Chris Thompson | '92 | Tennis |
| 1993 | Clifton Carpenter | '93 | Soccer |
| 1994 | Jason Van Matre | '94 | Football |
| 1995 | Seth Walters | '95 | Soccer |
| 1996 | Ryan Tewell | '96 | Crew |
| 1997 | Dean Phillips | '97 | Heavyweight Crew |
| 1998 | Timothy Limbert | '98 | Cross Country/Track |
| 1999 | Thomas Vanderhorst | '99 | Football |
| 2000 | Jon Brianas | '00 | Lacrosse |
| 2001 | Andrew Sause | '01 | Water Polo |
| 2002 | Barry Shaw | '02 | Water Polo |
| 2003 | Derek Jaskowiak | '03 | Football |
| 2004 | Marshall Boyd | '04 | Swimming |
| 2005 | Ralph Lufkin | '05 | Track & Field |
| 2006 | Tanner Garrett | '06 | Wrestling |
| 2007 | Todd Carlson | '07 | Water Polo |
